“WE have spoken, but are THEY listening?”

From student protests in France and electoral disputes in India to military rule in Myanmar and fierce political polarisation in Brazil, the world’s political upheavals could hardly appear more different. Documenting them all would take far more than a few pages, perhaps entire volumes. Yet, beneath their seemingly distinct causes, grievances, and consequences, they recount a similar story. Whom do citizens trust to represent them and count their votes? And most importantly, what happens when they stop trusting the institutions themselves?

In France, this question has moved from the National Assembly to the streets. What began as protests by high-school students over inadequate staffing, deteriorating school conditions, long hours and overcrowded classrooms has rapidly escalated into a nationwide movement. Hundreds of schools have been affected, and clashes between protesters and police left hundreds of students and staff injured. The government has acknowledged that the students’ grievances are legitimate while condemning the violence surrounding the protests.

What makes the French protests particularly significant is not simply the issue of education, but rather the protesters’ ages. These are young citizens beginning to enter political life, yet are already questioning whether the state is capable of providing something as fundamental as a functioning education system. Their aim goes beyond better classrooms; it is a demand to be heard. With the presidential election approaching, the protests have also acquired a wider political significance. The question here remains: “When young people turn to protest, are they demonstrating a fundamental loss of trust in government?”

Thousands of kilometres away, in India, the same question of being heard has taken a very different form. Protests have erupted over revisions to electoral rolls, with demonstrators demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. Opposition parties and protesters allege that the revisions have removed millions of eligible voters and could benefit Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party. The Election Commission and the BJP deny the allegations, while the Commission claim the revisions are intended to remove duplicate, deceased or otherwise ineligible entries while protecting electoral integrity.

But the stakes extend beyond party politics. An electoral roll determines who gets a voice in choosing their government. If eligible voters are wrongly excluded, their right to participate in democracy is compromised. Consequently if citizens come to suspect that the institution overseeing elections is not impartial, even the legitimacy of the results may be called into question.

So, that leaves us asking: “What happens to democracy when people stop trusting the referee?”

In Myanmar, the question of political trust reaches its most extreme form. After the military seized power in 2021, the country descended into a devastating civil war. Elections held in late 2025 and early 2026 were widely criticised:major opposition forces were excluded, voting could not take place across large parts of the country and the military retained overwhelming political control. Min Aung Hlaing, the military leader behind the coup, became president in April 2026. Myanmar isn’t simply choosing who becomes president; it’s choosing what direction its political institutions will take. “If the military controls the state, can political processes be democratic?”

Ultimately, Brazil offers a sharp picture of political polarisation at the ballot box. On October 4, Brazilians voted in a fiercely contested first round between incumbent Lula and Flávio Bolsonaro, son of former president Jair Bolsonaro. Yet this rivalry reflects more than competing political visions: it reveals a country divided over leadership, democratic values and the direction of its future. When political allegiance becomes deeply entrenched, opponents can begin to see one another not simply as people with different opinions, but as threats to the country itself. Such divisions can erode trust in political institutions and make compromise increasingly difficult. Brazil’s election is therefore more about who becomes president: it tests how a divided society can continue to govern itself. When does political loyalty become political division?

France, India, Brazil and Myanmar may seem to tell four completely different political stories. But beneath the protests, elections and institutional crises lies the same uncomfortable question: do people still trust the systems that claim to represent them? Democracy does not survive merely by holding elections; it survives when people believe their voices are actually being heard. Perhaps the critical political issue of our time is not who wins elections or which governments fall, but whether citizens still believe their voices matter.

龍

Leave a Reply