Appropriation of Asian Cultural Heritage in Luxury Fashion Industry: A Frown of Dongshi in Modern Days

In an old Daoist fable, it tells the story of a woman called ‘Dongshi’ who admired the great beauty ‘Xi Shi’. One day, she saw Xi Shi knit her eyebrows due to chest pain caused by her heart condition. She looked gorgeous even in that situation; thus, Dongshi decided to copy her frown, hoping to borrow the charm. Yet her lack of understanding caused her to perform the action in an exaggerated manner frightening the other villagers away. Centuries later, this fable has been derived into a Chinese idiom, Dongshi xiao pin (东施效颦), usually used to mock an imitator for copying without learning something internally, thus missing its essence.

Cultural appropriation is, according to Cambridge Dictionary, “an act of taking or using things from a culture that is not your own, especially without showing that you understand or respect this culture”. As creators are, of course, unwilling to let others free ride on their effort, plagiarism shrinks the creative markets. In this light, Intellectual Property rights were introduced to protect innovation by giving creators exclusive control over their work. Based on the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO), an IP can be legally protected through patents, copyrights, trademarks, industrial designs, geographical indications, and trade secrets.

The fashion industry, however, is an awkward test of that claim. It thrives despite weak protection against copying, as copying accelerates trend cycles and forces designers to keep innovating. Legal scholars, Karl Raustiala and Christopher Jon Springman, coined this as “the piracy paradox”. Thus, how Asian cultural symbols and practices are transformed when they enter global fashion markets, and how questions of ownership and recognition are negotiated within contemporary legal and commercial systems.

The Kolhapuri chappal, a traditional, handmade leather sandal originated from western India. It is named after the city of Kolhapur, in the state of Maharashtra. It stands out for its rich history dating back to the 12th century, then flourished under royal patronage. Its leather is soft and silky, traditionally tanned with medicinal plants such as “Hirada” and “Babul”. Its natural pores are also said to keep the feet cool.

As the cost of raw materials climbed by half or more, alongside with the low sales and high end brands market, authentic Kolhapuri makers struggled to sustain its production. Ironically, another fashion house located miles away from India, Prada, presented its replica at the 2025 Milan Fashion Week, selling it at a price many times higher than the original. In the aftermath, Bollywood actress Kareena Kapoor Khan shared a picture of her wearing the traditional footwear on Instagram, captioned, “Sorry not Prada … but my OG Kolhapuri.”

However, the journey to justice for Kolhapuri chappal was not easy, as it has no patent protection. In 2019, it was granted a Geographical Indication (GI). A GI is normally dedicated to crops, foodstuffs, beverages, handicrafts or industrial products that have a “specific geographical origin and possess qualities or a reputation that are due to the origin”. It prevents a third party from using the place-name on products that do not meet the applicable standards as the original producer. Yet, loopholes do exist: it does not hold agents who make a similar product with the same techniques under a different name accountable. Most importantly, due to its territoriality, GI has no direct force beyond national borders.

A Public Interest Litigation (PIL) was then filed by six advocates in the Bombay High Court, calling for an urgent judicial intervention, and to Prada, for a public apology and compensation to the local artisans. Yet, the PIL was dismissed in a fortnight, as the petitioners were not the registered GI proprietors and therefore lacked standing in this case.

Prada eventually acknowledged that the sandals were inspired by traditional Indian footwear and opened talks with artisans. If viewed from another perspective, this controversy indeed drove public interest in Kolhapuri sandals, seeming like a win-win. However, is it not disappointing that a global controversy may be the only way Asian cultural heritage gets noticed? With Prada setting a precedent, similar issues might reoccur in the future, yet with similar insufficient solution as no compensation was announced, and no individual artisan were named. After all, the spotlight stayed on Prada rather than on the craft or its makers, which weakens the claim that Prada brought attention to the artisans.

In conclusion, globalisation lets knowledge travel freely, but knowing where a culture comes from still matters. More importantly, appropriation is sometimes paired with distortion, when the essence of a culture could not be truly understood and translated, just like how the frown of Dongshi could never perform as she wished. Like a broken window left unrepaired, each unpunished borrowing invites the next, and we never know which culture could be next . Thus, the netizens should also act as watchdogs to reduce the chance of future cultural appropriation reoccur;. Vigilance must continue. Until the law attaches real consequences, it will remain easier to ask forgiveness than permission.

龍

Leave a Reply