News from the Railways: The Beginnings of Tram Line C

by Beau Sansoni

All images credited to the author.

↑ Above: Standard Havrais Alstom Citadis 302 

Le Havre was once a city criss-crossed by the tracks of railcars. All corners of the city would be reachable via these movable steel boxes, whether it be from the downtown to the upper city, or the docks into the suburbs. These trams would, with the beginning of the age of the automobile, begin to decline and die out as buses and cars dominated the streets. This had followed a worldwide trend, at a time of cheap gas, where countries could replace their ageing tram fleets with buses, or offload the costs to consumers through encouraging car ownership. 

Le Havre, as many cities had, aimed to revive its tram network in the early 2000s. The clear aim of the network, which can be seen by analysing the route, was to bring the suburbs and city centre closer together. While it is not as extensive, each tram car is much larger than their early 20th century counterparts, allowing for decent capacity despite the smaller network. 

The current network in Lines A & B extends to the upper city, past the chalk hills in the north of Le Havre. However it did not connect eastward, towards the suburbs and the older mediaeval towns past them. They were connected to Le Havre, though, not by bus or tram, but by a short train line which runs a singular carriage or two carriages along the line at a time. This line was known as the LER, or Lezarde Express Regionale, and it connected Le Havre to the ancient port at Harfleur, and the old abbey city at Montivilliers. It also connected you to a station at Graville in the suburbs, to l’Hopital Jacques Monod, and also, a few times a day, to Rolleville.

However, as of the 1st of September 2024, the line has been permanently closed, and replaced by a fleet of buses (specifically 11, 11 Express, and 21) which will ferry passengers to the old stations. The reason for its closure is for work on the third tram line for Le Havre: Tram Line C. Not only will it cover the old stations at Graville, Harfleur, l’Hopital Jacques Monod, and Montivilliers (but not Rolleville), but also new stations along the way and in the south-eastern Quartier de l’Eure. 

The eastern and south-eastern sections connect at the centre through the Gare du Havre, merging with Lines A & B which were already running on the same stretch of track. For the future student of Sciences Po, this tramway will connect them to the rest of the city, and further to the Quartier de l’Eure through a station at Les Docks, on the same road as the nearby Twenty Campus. I’d argue it’d help students reach the University of Le Havre’s Crous canteen, however in the three years until it finishes construction, I would be surprised if there was not a local canteen for the campuses in this area.

Above: The LER operating at Harfleur

Regardless, the current plans are for a public inquiry, which may be occurring now, followed by construction works from 2025 to 2027, which will be when the city attempts to begin operations on the new line. The new line will open 17 new stations from Vallée Béreult, just east of the Quartier de l’Eure, towards les Docks and the Gare du Havre, before unmerging at the University and heading east past la Stade Océane and terminating at Montivilliers. The city claims this would amount to 14 kilometres of new railway track, which would service around 9,000 university students. These new stations would be paired with new amenities such as a net addition of 300 planted trees, alongside new bike (and car for some) parking at each station. They further claim that the carbon footprint of the project will be 80 times less than of someone taking their own car.

As someone who is interested in urbanism, I believe that this project will be beneficial to those who live in the areas to which this railway will  go. It will help the city reduce its carbon footprint.                                  

and expand the amount of areas that can be traversed without using a  car. It will reduce journey times (supposedly 10 minutes from Gare to Vallée Béreult, and 25 minutes from Gare to Cité des Abbesses) across the city, and will allow for ease of transit for those unable to drive or those who are disabled. While not an expert, I do worry about the amount of traffic being ferried from three different tram lines using the same stretch of track from Université and Gare, and that it may lead to more delays. However, with improvements in signalling, I’m fairly confident in the smooth running of the system. 

This article is dedicated to the times in which I took the LER into Harfleur and Montiviliers. While useful, it was at certain points of the day an underutilised line, and the aged stations showed the need for its modernization. It had been running since 2001 on the same route its predecessors had taken in the 20th century. This new line, which has been long in the planning, will serve not only this old route of the LER, but also future Sciences Po students and those in the suburbs in both the south and east. I would highly recommend a visit to the Le Havre Seine Métropole website in order to see a map of the incoming Line C route, along with renders of the new stations and further details on the plan.

“It’s very important for us to take the climate narrative and make it local.” Dr. Fengshi Wu on environmental movements in Asia

By Syontoni Hattori-Chatterjee 

After the results of the U.S. presidential election became decisively known around the world, I admittedly spent the rest of Wednesday, November 6th, in a depressive slump. I was scared not only for the future of American democracy, economic management, and domestic climate policy, but also worried about the potential regressive impacts of this closely watched election on global environmental governance. Dr. Fengshi Wu’s talk with students the following day on the dynamics of environmental protests worldwide gave me a much needed boost of hope. 

The Associate Professor of Political Science and International Relations at UNSW Sydney first passionately presented her work on the history of environmentalist movements around the world. But as she critically emphasized, most of the activists of these movements, including Filipino protesters against World Bank-funded hydropower dams that would displace Indigenous communities in the 1980s, did not define themselves as environmentalists. The resistance of activists like Chico Mendes to protect the Amazon rainforest consisted of directly impacted individuals and communities fighting for the land that they lived on, the air they breathed, and the water and food sources they needed to survive. These kinds of deeply local struggles for survival were and still are shared across societies, from democratic to authoritarian and everything in between. I was convinced by Dr. Wu’s assertion that the lifeblood of environmental movements lies in their ability to take climate change and biodiversity issues from the global level to the local, and thereby speak to the immediate needs of communities facing these issues now. I also found it striking how she connected ground-level mobilization of communities addressed to direct threats such as air pollution in Pakistan or the disappearance of a river representing a sole potable water source in Kazakhstan to the triple influence of local laws, national policy, and international funding from organizations like the World Bank. 

I was reminded of the work of Julian Aguon, Chamorro human rights lawyer and founder of Blue Ocean Law, a Guam-based international law firm specializing in Indigenous rights and self-determination and environmental justice cases in the Pacific. I heard him speak two years ago at California State University Northridge’s Fifth Civil Discourse and Social Change initiative Social Justice Student Research Conference. Also an author, Aguon discussed using environmental activism as responsible grief work to process the loss of lifeways, family, and tradition as a result of climate change and a means of driving people past cynicism to environmental justice action through personal stories. Both Aguon and Wu’s presentations were factual but passionate, analyzing a web of international organization-state-community interactions at the level of people and their immediate survival. The presentations moreover advocated vigorously for the centrality of the most marginalized and most impacted communities in our notion of environmental activism. 

I also appreciated how Dr. Wu clearly and deftly illustrated some key distinctions between environmental movements in different contexts. Her research showed her that the major difference between protests occurring within a democratic context of rule of law versus a context without these guarantees was the level of repression, violence, and loss of life that protestors faced from the state. Nevertheless, she demonstrated that environmental movements worldwide are facing increasing repression, a symptom of democratic backsliding given that such movements have often pushed for political liberalization. She responded to audience questions clarifying that environmental politics’ being depicted as a left-wing, abstract political issue is a problem within Western democracies that does not translate to many other political contexts where the issue is more universalized. She also discussed national and global environmental governance in China, a uniquely high-functioning authoritarian regime whose renewable energy tradition is more driven by fossil-fuel-poor geographic conditions than existential concerns about the ecosystem. I found it especially illuminating to compare this strongly state-led environmental policy model to the contrasting behavior of the rising Chinese middle class, finally able to enjoy comfortable lifestyles of overconsumption that the middle classes of Western democracies have for decades, and thus, understandably, reluctant to forego its new lifestyle. As an American concerned about further U.S. removal from global climate governance, it was interesting to observe a different model that could become the future of environmental leadership in international relations. 

I am sure that I speak for my peers in expressing my gratitude to Havrais Dire for organizing this conference amidst what is always a busy (and perhaps draining) time studying political science in the tumultuous world we live in today. I hope that sharing some of my reflections on Dr. Fengshi Wu’s presentation through this article gives other students a similar renewed hope in our power to affect local change for global environmental progress. 

A Time Capsule From Integration Week

The good, the bad, and the busy from your fellow SciencesPistes.

By Syontoni Hattori-Chatterjee

Remember integration week? Do the performances and parties feel a million miles away amidst the trenches of midterms season? Here’s a reminder of times past when Le Havre weather was warm and Sciences Po life had the promise of fun. 

Sweet Memories

SPE and LH Sessions’ Beach Concert and Stargazing. Photo credit: Thomas Funkleder.

Nara, 1A: “Integration week was super fun! All of the assos, along with SciencesPo made everything accessible to everyone and there were tons of activities to choose to attend. For most of the 1As it’s our first time being away from home, so I appreciate the support system our 2As and admin made available for us to help us settle down and integrate. By Saturday, the day of Appartathon, I think everyone warmed up to each other and experienced lots of “core memory” things. I’m positive everyone was able to find their people and feel comfortable being here thanks to integration week.”

BDA and LH Sessions Jam Session and Bar Night. Photo credit: Julos Dartiguenave.

Yu Xuan, 2A Year Rep: “Integration week was such a blur for me and I felt like the week passed by in a flash! I absolutely loved the vibe of the campus though, everyone was so kind, lovely, and so open to discovering new cultures during the club & cultural fair! Always so fun for me to see new faces and meet y’all cutiepies! <333” 

Hard Work Behind the Scenes

Club Fair. Photo credit: Thomas Funkleder.

Humshinee, 2A and Street Dance Co-Captain and Musical Logistics Captain: 

“As a club leader, thinking about integration week is the best part of the summer. As the Street Dance Captains, Morgane and I started talking in Early August about ideas and it was amazing but difficult to create new choreography. We had a video call at 10 pm Morgane’s time and 4 pm my time during which we made new choreography in 30 minutes and then at 3 am my time and 9 am Morgane’s time to finish it. The crew learned it in 2 hours and then performed it the next day. 

As 2As, we were just so excited to be able to showcase to 1As, and let it be on the record that I was sick during the Club Fair, but through sickness and jetlag we all powered through. For the Musical Club, we were rehearsing starting at 9 am the day before the Club Fair. Laura landed at 8 am, then came into Le Havre at 3 pm, ate lunch and showered, and came to rehearse at 4 pm. I had so much anxiety seeing if we could pull everything together and Tuesday was running in between clubs and performances, from Shatta to Musical to Cheer. But overall, showcasing our clubs was so worth it. 

On Monday, meeting everyone at the beach and singing was super fun. Big ups to LH Sessions for reaching out over the summer and seeing what people were willing to do. On Thursday, it was so fun coming back to Craft a year later. I remembered seeing our now 3As perform last year so it was cool being on the other side of it. 

As a whole, as a Club Captain and Performer, my main goal and takeaway from integration week was to have fun and showcase what LH is all about and the relationships that we’ve built over the past year and will continue to build this year.”

Club Fair. Photo credit: Thomas Funkleder.

Sara, 2A and President of PROPA:

Je dirais que c’était beaucoup de stress, énormément de stress, en fait c’était vraiment une pression que je me mettais et que je pense tous les autres membres des associations se mettaient parce qu’on veut donner aux 1A une semaine d’intégration et WEI incroyable pour qu’ils se fassent des souvenirs incroyables comme nous on a pu se faire des souvenirs aussi incroyables l’année dernière.

C’était beaucoup de pression, voir même certains mental breakdowns mais au final, quand on voit les réactions des 1A qui viennent directement nous voir et nous remercier pour ce qu’on fait et nous dire qu’ils ont adoré que ce soit la semaine d’intégration ou le WEI et juste quand on les voit et qu’ils s’amusent, franchement ça en vaut la peine. 

Mais honnêtement ça me fait vraiment plaisir de voir qu’ils adorent parce que franchement moi je me rappelle que l’année dernière ma semaine d’intégration et mon WEI j’avais adoré, encore maintenant on en parle avec mes amis donc j’avais envie qu’ils aient exactement les mêmes émotions et les mêmes souvenirs que moi j’ai pu avoir l’année dernière en tant que 1A.”

Translation: 

“I’d say that it was a lot of stress, an insane amount of stress, but really it was pressure that I was putting on myself and that I think all of the other association members were putting on themselves because we want to give 1As an incredible integration week and WEI so that they could make incredible memories just as we did last year. 

It was a lot of pressure, even some mental breakdowns but in the end, when we see the reactions of 1As who come directly to see us and to thank us for what we’re doing and to tell us that they loved integration week or WEI and even just when we see them and they’re enjoying themselves, honestly it’s worth it.

And honestly it makes me really happy to see that they loved it because truly I remember last year that I adored my integration week and WEI, even now I talk about it with my friends, so I wanted them to have the exact same feelings and memories that I got to have last year as a 1A.” 

Some of the Best Sciences Po Traditions 

PROPA Appartathon. Photo credit: Fatine Mohattane.

Alex, 1A: “So I thought integration week was very entertaining since lots of different associations held various events. Almost every single one of them were fun and it was a great chance to [get to] know new people, both 1As and 2As. WEI, on the other hand, was also very fun and I could see that BDE and PROPA had put a great effort into it. The events were entertaining but the best part was definitely the 2 party nights! To be honest I think this tradition must be kept forever in SciencesPo.”

WEI. Photo credit: Enxin (Rosie) Han.

Rosie, 1A: “This was my first exposure to one of the best freshman traditions of SciencesPo – a very happy first weekend. I really enjoyed playing games with my classmates, making marshmallows, swimming, dancing, singing…etc. And I‘ve also met many people who are super interesting. We walked on the lawn together and looked up at a sky thick with stars like ice crystals, flashing and flickering, with beer… this atmosphere, it’s super super nice. I thought I will always miss my 18-year-old WEI trip, en France.”

BDA MuMA Visit. Photo credit: Thomas Funkleder. 

HD and BDA Cultural Fair. Photo credit: Syontoni Hattori-Chatterjee.

Been There, Done That  

Anya, 2A: “As a 2A it made me very grateful for the friends I had because I saw all of the 1As in the process of making friends and it reminded me of the good friends I have.” 

Diva, 2A and somebody anonymously agreeing: “Glad I’m not a 1A. I have never been so fake as my first year integration week.”

The Most Mature and Reflective Tea You’ll Ever Read 

WEI. Photo credit: Nicky Punnnahitanon.

Nikki, 1A: “Before going to WEI my friends and I asked many seniors about what exciting things we could look forward to, and many of them hinted to us that we could expect the wildest things happening like couples sprouting up everywhere, condoms littered all over the place, many people getting wasted. I think many of us were excited to see such spicy stories unravel — at least I was hahaha. (Un)fortunately, I didn’t hear of anything scandalous at all, but certainly I found something way more exciting: countless platonic relationships that quickly blossomed and strengthened, from jumping into the pool together to the screaming our lungs out at parties, from playing truth or dare on the floor of our chalets to boulangerie-hopping in centre-ville together in the rain. I know that in the next two years, whenever I get a headache from PI or feel lost along the Silk Road, I’ll definitely think back to these memories and feel this snuggly warmth in my heart.

Also, I love that the BDE provided condoms – even though I felt like almost nobody ended up using them for the right purpose hahaha (my friends and I were dissecting a female condom in our own room, fascinated to be seeing it for the first time!!) This is very new for me, something I’d never expect to see back in Singapore where I went to high school because there, abstinence is still very much at the forefront of our sex education (possibly in Thailand where I originally grew up).

Initially I was shocked – likely shaped by the environment I’d grown up in, I instinctively wondered whether this would encourage potentially risky sexual interactions, but very quickly my friends and I started having discussions about it and I was amazed to discover just how open minded people around me are towards this initiative. I realized that the condoms helped normalize safe sex and conversations about it, and as we grow up, we together can do so much in spreading this open minded attitude in our workplace and the policies we’ll help push for in society!

Another highlight of WEI for me is the food – omg it was just so ✨incroyable✨ with the charcuterie buffet and biscoff panna cotta being on top of the list for me. Simply unforgettable. Changed my life.”

I hope this recap makes you think fondly of your integration week experience at Sciences Po, the first for our dear 1As and the last for us 2As soon to be spread around the world. Now get back to studying SciencesPistes, I’m sure you have work to do. 

Passing Finals 101: Sciences Po Edition

It’s that time of the year again! We know we’re all excited for Christmas trees, decorative ornaments, elaborate lighting—all in preparation for our favorite season, finals! Sciences Po students in Le Havre all excitedly walk to school, clutching their laptops and previous midterm papers in hopes of getting the best holiday gift yet: a beautiful double-digit 10/20 score on their final papers. As the weather improves this holly jolly season, we at LDD have prepared an acronym – GO RATS – to help all students memorize these essential studying tips.

  1. G: Get Help. Academics are hard. If you’re struggling, remember that you have many resources available to help you succeed. Your local friendly drunkards at the Gare du Havre provide an interesting example of sociological phenomena taking place in the real world that you can add to your dissertation.
  2. O: Open Your Mind. It is important to think about your future after your exams, in case you flunk out of school. There are a myriad of possibilities. You can be an Uber Driver, a garbage collector, or even an SNCF employee who argues with you, gaslights you, and delays all the trains. The opportunities are endless!
  3. R: Reward Yourself. Studying will feel less like a chore if you set up a healthy reward system. For each one of Gretchen’s slides you read, take a shot of vodka. It will enhance your concentration and passive recall. Even better idea: the morning of your foreign language final, make sure to be a little tipsy – it will definitely improve your speaking performance.
  4. A: Acceptance. Accept your strengths. Accept your weaknesses. Accept defeat. 
  5. T: Take Breaks. Studying can be stressful! Taking breaks is essential for your sanity and mental health. For every hour of studying, reward yourself with one episode of the critically acclaimed Emily in Paris, so that even when you’re not studying you’re still enriching yourself with true French culture. Or, if you’re feeling a bit adventurous, book a flight to the United States of America during Revision Week – it’s short, inexpensive, and provides a good ambiance for studying. 
  6. S: Sleep. Everyone knows that sleep affects your performance. After all, you can’t beat the adrenaline rush of pulling an all-nighter. Make sure to minimize the amount of sleep you get, so that when you walk into the exam hall, the stress from the night before will carry you to victory!

We hope that you will take “GO RATS!” into account when studying. And as a bonus holiday gift for you, here’s a bonus tip: don’t procrastinate. Or else, Hauchecorne will send out another email. Enjoy the winter season!

Read more: Passing Finals 101: Sciences Po Edition

Monthly satirical article by Asher Seet and Noelani Aung

L’opium, arme de guerre.

Par Pr. Sophie Rochefort-Guillouet

On connaît mieux les résultats militaires et diplomatiques des guerres de l’Opium, qui opposèrent la Chine à la Grande Bretagne, que les raisons profondes de leur déclenchement.


Continue reading “L’opium, arme de guerre.”