Why do film photography in the age of AI?

Growing up I became used to the idea of being the subject of many photographs. My great grandma, Omi, proudly collected photos of her loved ones in individual albums, up to five per person or until we became big enough to go to the shared family one. I have vivid memories of the afternoons spent in her study, where her massive collection was meticulously kept. Altering her methodic order, I would take every single photo out and spread them all over her carpet, fascinated by how I could compare me and my mom, both sporting a tooth gap at the age of five. Or that I could see my grandpa as a plump baby and, at the same time, as a teen wearing bell bottom pants. My grandparents’ wedding, my grandma wearing a flower crown and a beige dress; I was amazed that I could peek into family vacations I hadn’t been to, meet once more the long gone family dogs inside my (maybe too) tight embrace and be a witness of the passage of time.

Image Credit: Maria Isabel SCHWARCZ LIGABUE

When photography became an obsession of mine, Omi decided to gift me her two point and shoot cameras that accompanied my childhood. Now, every time I wonder about the role of photography in my life, I can’t help but think of Omi, who never hesitated to look at the world and the people around her with immense care.

In Omi’s albums, I can identify the subtle transition between her film and digital photos, namely the change in the colours and grain. What interested me when going through her memory cards, was the discovery of pictures portraying landscapes, nature, sunsets and personal trips. This changed the way I thought of photography : rather than solely a mean to save memories, I came to see it as one to pick out what we admire. Their finding got me wondering about the non-existing negatives or her earlier photos. What happens to the physical part of photography when we already have the image we wanted? Is photography a material process or is the material condition only a stage for the image creation?

Image Credit: Maria Isabel SCHWARCZ LIGABUE

By asking myself those questions I started wondering what photography really is – what distinguishes an image from a good photograph and what value it carries.  Film or digital: a dichotomy between photography as a form of art and photography as a process to document our personal lives.


Photography literally translates from ancient Greek as “painting with light”. This meaning explains both film photography ( consisting of the camera as a mechanism with which you regulate the entrance of light that will then leave an impression onto the photosensitive negative)  and digital (same process but instead of a negative, light hits the sensor). But it doesn’t answer my central question: Is the negative a physical trace of what we saw or a trace of the image construction?

All these questions are also deeply connected to the reality I experience today with social media, one that is remarkably different from whatI experienced as a child, flicking through photo albums.

Image Credit: Maria Isabel SCHWARCZ LIGABUE

It’s estimated that around a trillion film photographs were taken in history; this is less than the photographs we currently take in a year with digital photography.

Tellingly, when scrolling through  Instagram, we encounter more images in fifteen minutes than we would encounter  in a museum over several hours. I have full memory cards that I’ve never gone through; most pictures in my iphone gallery are forgotten. Up until last year, I had  never seen my photographs on a bigger screen than my computer’s. Yet photographs cannot be reduced to mere megapixels and  the images we look at on Instagram for less than a second are completely disposable; the real value of photography will never fit a screen.

When I started shooting on film everything changed. Film imposes limits: there is no autofocus, nor automatic point-and-shoot function, nor endless gigabytes and least of all 36 exposures. It takes time to find a subject, focus on it, regulate your camera around it. Instead of instantly knowing if I got the shot, I would have to wait weeks for the moment to revisit the pictures I’d only envisioned. Film photography brought back an intentionality that I forgot even existed.

Image Credit: Maria Isabel SCHWARCZ LIGABUE

Additionally, we are not only experiencing a technological revolution driven by AI, but we are also the first generation to face its impact without knowing the consequences.

If I had to take a wild guess, I’d say it’s already robbing us of the ability to notice the world that unfolds around us without filters. To take a camera and walk the streets looking for traces of humanity, is my way of fighting for the version of reality I’d like to be part of. My negatives, at the end of the day, are a testament to that.

龍

Image Credit: Maria Isabel SCHWARCZ LIGABUE